How to Find a Trading Mentor: 7 Questions That Actually Matter (2026)
By Ken Chigbo, Founder, KenMacro. UK macro desk, 18 years institutional FX. Educational, not financial advice.
The short answer
Seven questions, in order. How many active mentees do you have right now (under ten is the only honest answer for 1-on-1 work). Will you read my last two months of trades before any advice (the audit step is non-negotiable). What is the written deliverable I leave with (a personalised rule set, not a video library). Do you have a verifiable desk or fund background (institutional FX, prop, or real macro role, not a chart screenshot). Do you turn applicants away (a mentor who takes everyone is a salesman). What is the recovery maths on this investment for my specific account size (real mentors know your numbers). Who is this NOT for (a real mentor will name three profiles they decline). If a mentor cannot answer those seven cleanly, the marketing is louder than the work, and you are paying for content.
Free macro framework
Reading the macro? Get the framework behind it.
The free regime-first framework the desk uses to read every session. Sent straight to your inbox.
Three-week 1-on-1 cohort. Application only. Reviewed personally.
The desk’s filter
If you trade your own account and the leak is behaviour not information, this is the work.
The mentorship is built for traders who already have a framework and want a desk in the seat with them while they execute. If you are pre-MTB, start with the free framework instead, the link is at the foot of this page.
Question 1: How many active mentees right now?
This is the single most useful question and almost nobody asks it. A real 1-on-1 trading mentor has fewer than ten active mentees at any one time because the work is genuinely time-bound. A careful per-mentee trade review takes thirty to ninety minutes; a mentor with twenty mentees doing the work properly would need ten to thirty hours a day for reviews alone. So if the mentor cannot or will not name a number under ten, they are running a course with private chat access, not 1-on-1 mentorship. There is nothing wrong with a course; just price it and frame it as one. The follow-up question, just as useful: can you name the current cohort by first name. A mentor doing the work knows. A mentor running a content business does not, because the relationship was never personal in the first place. Ask both, and listen to whether the answer comes back instantly or whether the mentor has to think.
Questions 2 and 3: The audit step, and the written deliverable
Question two: will you read my specific last two months of trades before any generic strategy advice? This is the audit step. Without it, the mentor is teaching content, not mentoring. With it, they have a chance of fixing the one thing actually broken in your trading. Question three: what is the written deliverable I leave with? A real mentorship produces a co-signed, personalised rule set the trader keeps. Not a video library, not transcripts, not access to a community. The deliverable is what survives the engagement. If a mentor cannot describe the deliverable in one sentence, they have not built one.
Three-week 1-on-1 with the desk. Application reviewed personally.
Questions 4 and 5: Background and applicant rejection
Question four: what is your verifiable desk or fund background? Institutional FX, prop firm, hedge fund, or a real macro role is the credential that actually transfers. A screenshotted PnL or a YouTube subscriber count is not. Ask for the specific firm and the specific role and the specific years. A real mentor will say so without hesitation. Question five: do you turn applicants away, and what does an applicant who does not fit look like? A mentor who takes everyone is selling a transaction, not a mentorship. A mentor who can name three profiles they decline (pre-framework, in tilt, account too small to recover the investment) is being honest with themselves and with you about the engagement.
Questions 6 and 7: Recovery maths and who this is not for
Question six: what is the recovery maths on this investment for my specific account size? A real mentor knows the numbers. A trader on a five thousand pound account, with a rebuilt rule set, working clean and not giving back winners, recovers a three thousand pound mentorship inside two to four months without sizing up. A larger account recovers it faster, a smaller account does not, and the mentor should say so plainly. Question seven, the one that matters most: who is this NOT for? A real mentor names the wrong-fit profiles without being asked, because they are protecting you and themselves from a bad engagement. If the answer is “anyone serious can get value”, the answer is a sales pitch.
The seven-question mentor filter
- How many active mentees right now?. Under ten is the only honest answer for genuine 1-on-1 work.
- Will you audit my last two months of trades before any advice?. If no, it is a course, not mentorship.
- What is the written deliverable I leave with?. A personalised, co-signed rule set, not a video library.
- What is your specific desk or fund background?. Firm, role, years. Verifiable. Not a screenshot.
- Do you turn applicants away? Name three profiles you decline.. A mentor who takes everyone is a salesman.
- What is the recovery maths on this for my account size?. Real mentors know the numbers and will share them honestly.
- Who is this NOT for?. If the answer is ‘anyone serious’, the answer is marketing.
The application takes two minutes. The desk reads every one.
Frequently asked questions
What are the most important questions to ask a trading mentor before paying?
Seven, in order: how many active mentees do you have now, will you audit my last two months of trades before advice, what written deliverable do I leave with, what is your verifiable desk background, do you turn applicants away, what is the recovery maths on this investment for my account size, and who is this NOT for. If those answers are unclear or evasive, walk away.
How do I verify a trading mentor’s background?
Ask for the specific firm, the specific role and the specific years. Cross-check on LinkedIn. For institutional desks, ask about specific products they traded and at what size. A real mentor will give straight answers without flourish. Vagueness or deflection is the red flag.
How long should a real trading mentorship last?
Three to six weeks of true 1-on-1 work is the standard for a focused engagement. Shorter is usually a single intensive audit. Longer is usually a course with periodic 1-on-1 calls rather than continuous 1-on-1 work. Match the length to what you need fixed.
How much should a real trading mentor cost?
GBP 2,500 to GBP 5,000 for a genuine three to six week 1-on-1 engagement. Anything under GBP 500 is a course relabelled. Anything over GBP 10,000 usually includes capital allocation or fund-track components and is a different product.
Does KenMacro offer trading mentorship?
Yes. Ken Chigbo (London floor, 18 years institutional FX) runs a three-week 1-on-1 cohort. Audit week one, live work week two, independent run week three. Co-signed personalised rule set at the end. Application only. The link is in this article.
Sources and further reading
Related from the desk
For general education only. Trading carries risk. The desk does not provide personalised investment advice. The mentorship is for traders who already trade, with capital and process to build on.
More from the mentorship cluster
Apply the filter to a real decision: read these together.
Pick by where you are
Three tiers, one framework. Free PDF, the £499 Blueprint course, or £2,500-5,000 1-on-1 mentorship. The full comparison sits in one place.
From the desk, free
Get the macro framework the desk actually trades
The same regime-first framework behind every call on this site, plus the weekly macro brief. Free. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
Continue reading
From the desk
Where this gets traded
Reading the macro driver is half of it. The other half is an account that holds execution when the driver actually moves the tape. See the KenMacro desk guide to the best brokers for macro traders.
Read the desk guide →